Hidden Caribbean Gems: 5 Islands That Feel Like Your Own Private Paradise
- ER Kent
- Aug 2, 2025
- 3 min read
Looking to skip the cruise ship crowds and find your slice of Caribbean serenity? These five off-the-radar islands offer all the sun, sea, and sand—with none of the chaos
Why Go Beyond the Tourist Hotspots?
Most travelers heading to the Caribbean land in bustling hubs like the Dominican Republic, Aruba, or the Bahamas. But there’s a whole other side to the region—one of quiet beaches, authentic villages, untouched nature, and slow island rhythms. According to travel editors at The Times, smaller islands like Saba and Montserrat are seeing a rise in appeal among travelers seeking “castaway calm” without sacrificing beauty.
1. Saba – The Unspoiled Queen
Tiny and dramatic, Saba is just five square miles of volcanic cliffs and lush rainforest—yet its impact on visitors is huge. With fewer than 2,000 residents and no beaches (but world-class diving), it’s a haven for hikers, marine explorers, and those who crave quiet.
Annual visitor count: Approximately 15,000 Must-dos: Hike Mt. Scenery, dive in the Saba Marine Park, stay in a gingerbread guesthouse Best for: Nature lovers, divers, and travelers seeking an unplugged escape
2. Dominica – The Caribbean’s Nature Island
Not to be confused with the Dominican Republic, Dominica is a mountainous, rainforested paradise with 365 rivers, boiling lakes, and volcanic hot springs. It’s popular with eco-tourists and still delightfully under-visited compared to its neighbors.
There are no mega-resorts here—just family-run inns and eco-lodges.
Must-dos: Hike to Boiling Lake, snorkel Champagne Reef, and explore waterfalls like Trafalgar Falls
Best for: Adventure travelers and wellness seekers
3. Montserrat – A Phoenix Rising
Known for its tragic volcanic eruptions in the 1990s, Montserrat is now a resilient island rebounding in peace and beauty. The exclusion zone around the buried capital of Plymouth offers haunting views, while the north remains lush, green, and full of warmth.
With fewer than 15,000 annual tourists, this is truly an island where locals will remember your name.
Must-dos: Visit the Montserrat Volcano Observatory, hike to Rendezvous Bay, explore volcanic ruins
Best for: History buffs, solitude seekers, and those fascinated by nature’s power
4. Anegada – Low-Key Luxury in the British Virgin Islands
Unlike its mountainous BVI siblings, Anegada is flat and ringed by coral reef. It's ideal for bonefishing, snorkeling, and quietly kicking back at beach bars without the mega-resort crowd.
There are no cruise ships here, and just a handful of boutique inns and villas.
Must-dos: Spot flamingos, eat fresh lobster, kayak in salt ponds
Best for: Barefoot luxury, birding, and couples looking to disconnect
5. Vieques – Puerto Rico’s Secret Escape
Just off Puerto Rico’s east coast, Vieques is known for its wild horses, hidden beaches, and the world’s brightest bioluminescent bay. Because it’s accessible only by ferry or puddle-jumper, it remains largely under the radar for mainland tourists.
Even better? No passport is needed for U.S. travelers. Must-dos: Kayak Mosquito Bay at night, explore Playa Negra, visit the wildlife refuge Best for: Nature lovers, photographers, and families wanting adventure without airport hassle
Final Takeaway
Skip the crowds and uncover a side of the Caribbean that still feels personal, natural, and untouched. Whether it’s hiking through a rainforest in Dominica, diving untouched reefs in Saba, or watching wild horses gallop across the beaches of Vieques, these five hidden islands deliver the magic—minus the masses.
Comments